| Born Fighter a Senate Winner
By Tom Deignan
AT this point in history, an Irish Catholic in the U.S. Senate really
shouldn’t raise many eyebrows. Pennsylvania’s Bob Casey Jr.
was just elected over one-time conservative power broker Rick Santorum.
Perhaps the most fascinating thing about Casey is that he is not only
Catholic but also a Democrat who is generally opposed to abortion.
So, it’s certainly not a big a deal to have a Scots Irishman elected
to the Senate. After all, it was way back in the 1820s that the son of
Irish Protestant immigrants, Andrew Jackson, was elected president, technically
making him (and not John F. Kennedy) the first Irishman to make it to
the White House,
Nevertheless, this past Friday, when the tight Virginia U.S. Senate race
between Democrat Jim Webb and Republican Mark Warner was finally decided
-– a full three days after Election Day –- it marked the conclusion
of a fascinating Irish American story.
As far as U.S. politics, it was certainly a momentous occasion. The belated
Webb victory meant that the Democrats officially seized control of the
Senate, as well as the House.
But the Webb story is also of particular interest to Irish Americans.
It was about this time last year that Webb –- a decorated Marine
veteran who has a son fighting the war in Iraq –- was on the best-seller
lists and magazine covers with his book Born Fighting: How the Scots Irish
Shaped America.
The book is a personal as well as historical look at a group of Americans
who are often either ignored or looked down upon. They are also rarely
clumped together with Irish Catholic Americans.
According to Webb’s book, however (which he often made reference
to while campaigning), the Scots Irish not only influenced America in
profound ways, but they themselves were shaped by their journey from Ireland
primarily to the rough, mountainous frontier regions of the American south.
What makes Webb’s book -– and election victory -– so
interesting is that while he is proud of his roots and what his people
have accomplished, he is also combative, even angry. Webb, in short, is
not afraid to be confrontational. Then again, that’s pretty much
what he says the Scots Irish are all about.
“(The Scots-Irish) people gave our country great things, including
its most definitive culture,” he writes. “Its bloodlines have
flowed in the veins of at least a dozen presidents, and in many of our
greatest soldiers.
“It created and still perpetuates the most distinctly American form
of music. It is imbued with a unique and unforgiving code of personal
honor, less ritualized but every bit as powerful as the samurai code.
Its legacy is broad, in many ways defining the attitudes and values of
the military, or working class America, and even the peculiarly populist
form of American democracy itself.”
Despite this, however, Webb laments that the Scots Irish have often been
ignored, or depicted in a negative light. It has to be added that while
he might not state this explicitly, Webb is challenging Irish Americans
to change their view of what it really means to be Irish American, and
who exactly is included in that group.
Is it just Irish Catholics from New York, Chicago and Boston? For Webb,
that would be a mistake.
According to Webb, the Scots Irish “story has been lost under the
weight of more recent immigrations, revisionist historians, and common
ignorance.”
He later writes, “The contributions of this culture are too great
to be forgotten as America rushes forward into yet another redefinition
of itself. And in a society obsessed with multicultural jealousies, those
who cannot articulate their ethnic origins are doomed to a form of social
and political isolation.
“My culture needs to rediscover itself, and in so doing to regain
its power to shape the direction of America.”
Well, Webb has certainly done that with his Senate win. He was a critic
of President Bush’s Iraq war policy and now, having given the Democrats
a majority in the Senate, he can do something about it.
|