| How We Changed Papal Succession
By Tom Deignan
For the last week or so, the media has been busy explaining the intricate
and, of course, highly secretive process by which the next pope will be
selected.
There has been much talk of the “ancient” process, and the many traditions
which must be followed.
Of course, this is not entirely accurate. In fact, Pope John Paul II
himself had changed a number of rules about the process of papal succession.

Watching this entire spectacle unfold also calls to mind a small episode
from early in the 20th century involving the election of another pope. This
episode, when all was said and done, led to the alteration of a significant
rule regarding papal elections.
More broadly, it gave Irish American Catholics a chance to vent their
frustration, at a time when they were becoming increasingly powerful politically.
But, this episode also reminded American Catholics that then — and, one
could argue, now as well — they are not nearly as important as Europe when
it comes to global Catholicism.
The year was 1922. Pope Benedict XV had just died. Then, as now, cardinals
from around the world gathered to select a new pope.
The surprise choice would be Pope Pius XI, born Achille Ratti and made
a cardinal and archbishop of Milan just two years earlier in 1920.
Pius’ later relationships with Mussolini as well as Hitler would be the
source of much controversy. But before all that there was Pius’ election
itself.
Not only was Ratti’s selection as pope a surprise, it was also swift.
How swift? Well, as several newspapers, including The New York Times recently
noted, William Henry Cardinal O’Connell, Boston’s powerful archbishop, heard
about the election as he was still making his way to Rome.
O’Connell was the youngest of 11 children, whose parents came to Massachusetts
from Meath and Cavan. Back then, cardinals were told to take 10 days to
hold their “general congregations.” These are the deliberations going on
right now, and the required start of the process which will eventually lead
to the selection of a new pope.
Of course, back in 1922, world travel was not quite as easy as it is
now. Archbishop O’Connell — and the small contingent of American cardinals
required to be in Rome within 10 days — would have had a tough time making
plans, and then actually traveling.
O’Connell, for one, took a steamship to the Vatican. It took more than
a week, and he was not pleased to find out that the cardinals were not in
need of his assistance.
The American Catholic leadership, back then, almost exclusively Irish,
voiced a general displeasure at being taken for granted. It was, clearly,
a time of contradictions for Irish Catholics in the U.S.
True, the Al Smith debacle lay six years in the future. No way, yet,
could a Catholic be elected president of this heavily Protestant nation.
Still, Irish Catholics had come a long way by the 1920s. They had been
running major cities for decades, and a major part off their identity —
and one which many thought to be responsible for their success — was their
religion. They had enough to deal with when it came to lingering bigotry
here in the U.S.
And yet, here was the global leadership of the Catholic church saying,
essentially, “Don’t worry if you can’t get to us within 10 days to select
a new pope. We don’t need your vote. We’ll get on quite fine without you.”
In the short run Archbishop O’Connell and America’s Catholic leadership
got some satisfaction. As has been pointed out many times in recent days,
cardinals now take “15 to 20” days for general deliberations before the
voting process begins.
The irony, of course, is that it is a lot easier today to travel the
world in a matter of hours, much less days. So the extra time is not really
needed.
The other interesting thing, though, is this — speculation has it that
the next pope will be an Italian (a safe choice) or a candidate from Africa
or Latin America (the risky choice).
Obviously, there’s no mention of anyone from North America. So, it seems
Irish Catholics in the U.S. still fit quite uneasily in the global family
of the Catholic church.
(Contact Sidewalks at
tomdeignan@earthlink.net.)
|